a darkness returns by Raymond E. Feist marks the beginning of an ambitious new series that bridges his Firemane Saga with the beloved Riftwar Cycle. This novel is a testament to Feist’s mastery of epic fantasy, somehow constantly able to bring together intricate plots, rich character development, and expansive world-building.
The story follows Hatushaly, the last scion of the Firemane dynasty, along with his companions Hava and Donte, as they are transported from their war-torn world of Garn to the relative peace of Midkemia. On Sorcerer’s Isle, under the tutelage of the great magician Magnus and his reincarnated father Pug, Hatu must harness his unique magical abilities to save Garn from impending doom. The narrative is set against the backdrop of the Church of the One’s rise to power, bringing death and destruction to Hatu’s homeland. The kingdom of Ilcomen has fallen, and the Church’s forces are now targeting Marquensas, where Daylon Dumarch has declared himself king, and master swordsmith Declan Smith has been elevated to prince and war commander. However, the Church is not the only threat; beings from the Void, creatures born of Darkness, also loom large. If you are not a fan of Feist’s work, and you’re still with me - you’re doing well!
Feist’s ability to blend the lore of the Firemane Saga with the Riftwar Cycle is impressive. The novel features a large cast of characters, both new and familiar, including the iconic Pug and Nakor. This crossover creates a sense of nostalgia for long-time fans while introducing new readers to the expansive universe Feist has crafted over decades. The plot is engaging, with enchanting battle sequences, nautical intrigue, and a camaraderie among characters that is easy to root for.
However, the book is not without its flaws. It is likely that some newer readers may find the plot a bit convoluted, with numerous references to past events and characters that might be confusing for those not well-versed in Feist’s previous works. The story also feels rushed at times, with significant developments and clever solutions introduced and then quickly passed over. This can leave readers feeling as though they are missing out on deeper explorations of the characters and their motivations.
The characterisation, while generally strong, can sometimes feel thin. Hatu’s ability to effortlessly perform magic, for instance, may come across as too convenient, lacking the struggle and growth that typically make such journeys compelling. Other storylines definitely feel underdeveloped. His actions and motivations are not always clear, and his subplot often detracts from the main narrative rather than enhancing it.
Despite these issues, a darkness returns is a solid start to what promises to be an epic trilogy. Feist’s world-building remains top-notch, and his ability to create a sense of homecoming for long-time fans is commendable. The novel’s strengths lie in its expansive universe, engaging plot, and the nostalgic return of beloved characters. While it may not mesmerise readers in the same way as the Riftwar Saga or the Empire Trilogy, it is still an entertaining read that sets the stage for future instalments in the Dragonwar Saga.
In conclusion, a darkness returns is a must-read for fans of Raymond E. Feist and epic fantasy enthusiasts. It offers a blend of old and new, with a promise of more adventures to come. While it may have its shortcomings, the novel’s strengths far outweigh its weaknesses, making it a worthy addition to Feist’s impressive body of work.
Reviewer: Chris Reed
Voyager